UConn Mistaken on Pope

Pope Mistaken On Euthanasia - Commentary

Here we see the culture of death has returned to my alma mater. No accounting for taste.

Pope Benedict XVI denounced euthanasia over the weekend, once again proclaiming life a gift from God and asserting that it could not be terminated under "the guise of human compassion." The pontiff's announcement came after an Italian doctor was cleared of wrongdoing in an euthanasia case, and more or less echoed the statements made by Pope John Paul II during the 2004 Terri Schiavo case. While it is indeed the pope's prerogative to take a stance on such divisive issues, the purportedly infallible Benedict is undoubtedly mistaken on the issue of euthanasia. Without question, euthanazing a pain-wrought patient who is not going to recover is an act of genuine human compassion that should not be prohibited. Many terminal illnesses can be extremely painful to endure. In the event that a mentally-sound patient is afflicted with such a pernicious disease, it is his or her to right to end his or her life. To borrow from John Stuart Mill's "Harm Principle," an individual should have complete independence when engaging in self-regarding actions - actions that directly affect only the individual making these choices. Choosing how and when one's life ends is a choice that truly affects the individual making the choice, and thus falls under the category of choices that should not be regulated by any outside presence. Accordingly, it is not the place of the pope nor the state to interfere with one's decision to end one's life in the event of terminal illness.The pope ought to heed the words of Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, who contradicted the pontiff last month when he said that terminally ill patients deserve the right to refuse "unreasonably obstinate" treatment that will merely stave off inevitable death. While Martini does not support active euthanasia, i.e. administering a lethal injection to a dying patient, his nuanced perspective on the subject is appreciated, given the generally unyielding nature of the Vatican. Perhaps, in the future, a pope may come to realize, like Martini, that allowing a consenting party to die is not tantamount to murder. Societies proscribe murder because killing another human being entails violating his or her rights. In the case of an individual who wants to die, however, preserving life does not mean preserving one's rights - it means violating them. While the pope is right to believe that life deserves respect, he is wrong to maintain that all life must be continued. As evidenced by the will of some patients to die, some lives simply are not worth continuing. In these cases, euthanasia is the most rational and compassionate course of action.

The value of life goes beyond the visible - what is measured and even felt. Life is the gift and love is expressed from God and believers through life. By taking life into our hands we make ourselves like Gods. This is the sin which cast man from paradise- just because man can do something, does it mean he should?

Father, Please grant us the gift of respect of your Holy gifts, especially life. Let us not take any day for granted but see all as a gift from God.